This seems to be a fault with the charging indicator circuit and since the test indicates all the wiring are in good order and to replace the alternator, then most likely the alternator is faulty.
As I mentioned earlier, bench test only test the alternator performance, it can pass but the charge indicator ciruit fails because the bench test do not provide any test for it.
Get another alternator to test.
Aug 5, 2010 at 3:33 PM