My starter spins, but doesn't crank the engine

1998 NISSAN ALTIMA
180,000 MILES • 2.4L • 4 CYL • AUTOMATIC
Avatar
PUGG9116
  • MEMBER
  • 2 POSTS
My starter spins, but doesn't crank the engine. Car has always had trouble starting, believed to be a fuel and/or electrical issue that I've been trying to eliminate. Lately the starter has been starting to grind as it starts, we found a ground wire attached to the starter bolt had come uncrimped, therefore we assumed that was my problem.

However, a week later, it's back to free-spinning. It didn't grind like the last one did, just a little as it seemed closer to it's death when it stopped engaging the flex-plate. It started with minor difficulty this morning (kinda the usual) but ran like a champ for a couple hours, starting perfectly fine as its warmed up. Ironically I was picking up new injector o-rings, as I was planning to clean my injectors hoping to solve part of my problem. Just two hours after my commute, I tried starting again as I usually do. Typically it would fire up with little hiccups, but it seemed a little more violent trying to crank over (heavy shaking). Typically giving it a little throttle helps the process, this felt like it wasn't getting fuel. Then, mid-crank, the starter started free-spinning, now it'll catch for a split second before free-spinning, every time, just like the last one. My guess is that the starter is potentially good, but something is depriving the starter solenoid of power. This guess being that my last two replaced starters tested good in the parts store.

A little history about this car. I bought it from a friend who bought it as a fixer upper. Many things have been replaced since we've worked on it. We've replaced:

Tried replacing the relay and checked fuses, nothing. It's recently been re-timed at 20 degrees and I use 89 or better fuel most of the time.
Mar 25, 2019 at 12:32 PM
Advertisement
Avatar
SCGRANTURISMO
  • CERTIFIED EXPERT
  • 4,897 POSTS
This sounds like the starter is having problems or the battery needs to be load tested these guides can help us fix it. Here is a guide to help you step by step with instructions in the diagrams below to show you how on your car.

https://www.2carpros.com/articles/starter-not-working-repair

and

https://www.2carpros.com/articles/car-battery-load-test

Check out the diagrams (Below). Please let us know what you find.
Mar 25, 2019 at 4:07 PM
Avatar
PUGG9116
  • MEMBER
  • 2 POSTS
Oh, I know how it the starter works, and by tested "good" I mean tested and Bendix engaged as it should, teeth were damaged. Checked connections, they're still good, so I got another starter and it worked why do you think the first one was bad?
Mar 25, 2019 at 4:18 PM
Advertisement
Avatar
SCGRANTURISMO
  • CERTIFIED EXPERT
  • 4,897 POSTS
rebuilders can be sketchy try to get a name brand unit like Denso.
Mar 27, 2019 at 2:54 AM